On an NG MVPN, multicast data traffic is transmitted through an inclusive-provider multicast service interface (I-PMSI) tunnel to multicast users. The I-PMSI tunnel transmits multicast traffic to all PEs on the same MVPN, regardless of whether these PEs have receivers. If some PEs do not have receivers, this implementation causes traffic redundancy, wastes bandwidth resources, and increases PEs' burdens. Selective-PMSI (S-PMSI) tunnels can address the preceding issue. After multicast traffic data is switched from an I-PMSI tunnel to an S-PMSI tunnel, only PEs that have receivers can receive the traffic. Therefore, S-PMSI tunnels can prevent redundant traffic, reduce bandwidth consumption, and relieve the workload of PEs.